Top 10 Italian Restaurants in Florida
Italian Restaurants in USA

Top 10 Italian Restaurants in Florida

Cafe Prima Pasta

If you're looking for that quintessential, cozy, family-run Italian spot in Miami Beach, Cafe Prima Pasta is it, hands down. This place has been a local favorite for decades, tucked away on Washington Avenue, and it just exudes warmth and authenticity. You'll feel like you've walked into a bustling trattoria in Rome, with its intimate setting, dim lighting, and the delightful aroma of garlic and simmering tomato sauce filling the air. It's the kind of place where you can relax, enjoy great conversation, and truly savor every bite.

Their pasta dishes are legendary – think homemade ravioli, rich gnocchi, and a seafood linguine that will make your taste buds sing. The portions are generous, and the ingredients are always fresh. Pricing here is mid-range, making it accessible for a special night out without breaking the bank; expect to spend around $30-50 per person for a full meal with drinks. It's perfect for a romantic dinner or a lively gathering with close friends, and locals know to make a reservation, especially on weekends!

What Food Critics Say

Diners consistently praise Cafe Prima Pasta for its authentic flavors and charming, intimate atmosphere, often giving it a solid 4.5-star rating. Many rave about the fresh pasta and the friendly, attentive service, though some note that it can get quite busy and a bit noisy during peak hours – a testament to its popularity!

📍 Address: 414 Washington Ave, Miami Beach, FL 33139

Get a Discount

Special offers available
Make a Reservation

Book your table now
Get Directions

Open in Google Maps

Christini's Ristorante Italiano

Prepare yourself for an unparalleled fine dining experience at Christini's in Orlando. This isn't just a meal; it's an event. From the moment you step inside, you're enveloped in an atmosphere of classic elegance, with white tablecloths, impeccable service, and often, the delightful sounds of live music. Christini's has been a cornerstone of Orlando's upscale dining scene for years, known for its commitment to traditional Italian cuisine and an old-world charm that's hard to find elsewhere.

The menu is a celebration of Northern Italian classics, featuring exquisite veal dishes, perfectly cooked seafood, and pasta made with the finest ingredients. Their Osso Buco is a showstopper, and the tableside Caesar salad preparation is a delightful touch. This is definitely a splurge, with pricing typically in the $70+ per person range, making it ideal for special occasions, business dinners, or when you simply want to treat yourself to the very best. The attention to detail and the refined ambiance make it truly memorable.

What Food Critics Say

Christini's consistently earns high praise, often boasting a 4.7-star rating, for its exceptional service, elegant ambiance, and classic Italian dishes. Reviewers frequently highlight the consistency of quality and the luxurious dining experience, though some mention the higher price point as expected for such a caliber of restaurant.

📍 Address: 7600 Dr Phillips Blvd, Orlando, FL 32819

Get a Discount

Special offers available
Make a Reservation

Book your table now
Get Directions

Open in Google Maps

Casa D'Angelo

If you're in Fort Lauderdale and craving truly authentic, upscale Tuscan cuisine, Casa D'Angelo is where you need to be. This place is a local institution, renowned for its vibrant energy, sophisticated yet welcoming atmosphere, and a menu that transports you straight to the heart of Italy. Chef Angelo Elia, the mastermind behind it all, has created a dining experience that's both refined and incredibly flavorful, making it a go-to for discerning foodies.

You'll find an impressive selection of fresh seafood, perfectly grilled meats, and house-made pasta dishes that are simply divine. Don't miss their signature Veal Chop, or any of their daily specials, which often feature seasonal ingredients. The wine list is extensive and expertly curated to complement the rich flavors of the food. Pricing is on the higher end, typically $60-100+ per person, making it perfect for a celebratory dinner or a serious culinary indulgence. It's a place where you can linger, enjoy great company, and feel truly pampered.

What Food Critics Say

Casa D'Angelo is consistently rated around 4.6 stars, with diners frequently commending its authentic Tuscan flavors, extensive wine list, and lively, upscale atmosphere. While many praise the exceptional quality of ingredients and service, some note that it can be quite noisy due to its popularity, especially on busy nights.

📍 Address: 1201 N Federal Hwy, Fort Lauderdale, FL 33304

Get a Discount

Special offers available
Make a Reservation

Book your table now
Get Directions

Open in Google Maps

Il Mulino New York

For an exquisite taste of classic Abruzzese Italian cuisine with a touch of New York sophistication, you absolutely must experience Il Mulino New York in Sunny Isles Beach. Nestled within the luxurious Acqualina Resort, this restaurant offers an incredibly elegant and refined dining experience. From the moment you're seated, you'll be treated to impeccable service and a grand ambiance that makes every meal feel like a special occasion.

Their menu is a testament to traditional Italian cooking, with generous portions of perfectly prepared pasta, fresh seafood, and succulent meat dishes. The complimentary antipasto spread, including cured meats, cheese, and bruschetta, is a delightful start to your meal. Don't miss their famous Spaghetti Carbonara or the Dover Sole. This is a high-end dining experience, with pricing typically starting at $80+ per person, making it ideal for a truly luxurious evening out, perhaps celebrating an anniversary or a significant milestone.

What Food Critics Say

Il Mulino New York consistently receives high marks, often around 4.5 stars, for its luxurious ambiance, impeccable service, and classic, generous Italian dishes. Reviewers frequently highlight the complimentary appetizers and the overall upscale dining experience, though some mention the price point is reflective of its high-end nature.

📍 Address: 17101 Collins Ave, Sunny Isles Beach, FL 33160

Get a Discount

Special offers available
Make a Reservation

Book your table now
Get Directions

Open in Google Maps

La Trattoria

When you're strolling down Duval Street in Key West and craving some authentic Italian, La Trattoria is your vibrant, bustling answer. This place has a fantastic, lively atmosphere that perfectly captures the spirit of Key West – it's casual, fun, and always buzzing with energy. Whether you're looking for a romantic dinner on their charming patio or a lively meal inside, you'll feel right at home in this local favorite.

Their menu features classic Italian dishes with a focus on fresh seafood, given its Key West location. You'll find delicious pasta, wood-fired pizzas, and hearty entrees that are perfect after a day of exploring. Their Grouper Livornese is a standout, and the homemade tiramisu is the perfect sweet ending. Pricing is moderate, typically $25-45 per person, making it a great spot for families, couples, or a group of friends looking for a satisfying and authentic Italian meal without breaking the bank.

What Food Critics Say

La Trattoria generally holds a strong 4.3-star rating, with diners frequently praising its lively atmosphere, fresh seafood, and classic Italian dishes. Many appreciate its prime location on Duval Street and the friendly service, though some note that it can get quite busy and a bit loud during peak tourist seasons.

📍 Address: 524 Duval St, Key West, FL 33040

Get a Discount

Special offers available
Make a Reservation

Book your table now
Get Directions

Open in Google Maps

Grato

For a taste of modern Italian with a vibrant, energetic twist in West Palm Beach, Grato is an absolute must-visit. Helmed by acclaimed Chef Clay Conley, this spot brings a fresh, contemporary approach to Italian cuisine, focusing on wood-fired dishes and house-made pasta. The atmosphere is chic and lively, with an open kitchen that adds to the dynamic energy, making it a fantastic place for a fun night out with friends or a stylish date.

You absolutely have to try their wood-fired pizzas – the crust is perfectly charred and the toppings are creative and delicious. Their house-made pasta dishes are also exceptional, with unique flavor combinations that truly stand out. Don't skip the appetizers; they're designed for sharing and are incredibly flavorful. Pricing is mid-to-high range, typically $40-70 per person, offering a sophisticated dining experience that's still approachable. It's a place where you can enjoy innovative dishes in a buzzing, stylish setting.

What Food Critics Say

Grato consistently receives high praise, often around 4.4 stars, for its innovative modern Italian cuisine, particularly its wood-fired pizzas and house-made pasta. Reviewers frequently commend the lively ambiance and creative menu, though some mention that the noise level can be high due to its popularity.

📍 Address: 1901 S Dixie Hwy, West Palm Beach, FL 33401

Get a Discount

Special offers available
Make a Reservation

Book your table now
Get Directions

Open in Google Maps

Donatello Restaurant

Step back in time to an era of classic Italian romance and impeccable service at Donatello Restaurant in Tampa. This isn't just a restaurant; it's a Tampa institution, known for its old-world charm, elegant decor, and a truly intimate dining experience. With live music often filling the air, it's the perfect spot for a romantic evening or a special celebration where you want to feel truly taken care of.

The menu at Donatello is a tribute to traditional Italian cuisine, featuring timeless dishes prepared with care and precision. Their homemade pasta is a highlight, and the Veal Chop is consistently praised. The service is attentive without being intrusive, making you feel like a valued guest from the moment you arrive. Pricing is on the higher side, typically $50-80+ per person, reflecting the quality of the ingredients and the exceptional dining experience. It's a place where you can truly slow down and savor the moment.

What Food Critics Say

Donatello Restaurant is highly regarded, often holding a 4.5-star rating, for its classic Italian ambiance, live music, and exceptional service. Diners frequently praise the traditional dishes and the romantic atmosphere, though some note that the decor feels a bit dated, which for many, adds to its old-world charm.

📍 Address: 232 N Dale Mabry Hwy, Tampa, FL 33609

Get a Discount

Special offers available
Make a Reservation

Book your table now
Get Directions

Open in Google Maps

Campiello

If you find yourself in beautiful Naples and craving an upscale, authentic Tuscan experience, Campiello on 3rd Street South is an absolute must-visit. This place is simply stunning, with a gorgeous courtyard dining area that feels like a little slice of Italy, complete with twinkling lights and a lively, sophisticated buzz. It's the perfect spot for a special evening out, combining elegant ambiance with truly delicious food.

The menu at Campiello focuses on fresh, seasonal ingredients, crafting traditional Tuscan dishes with a refined touch. Their wood-fired pizzas are fantastic, and the house-made pasta dishes are always a hit. Don't miss their fresh seafood specials or the perfectly grilled meats. Pricing is on the higher end, typically $50-90+ per person, but the quality of the food, the impeccable service, and the enchanting atmosphere make it well worth it. It's a place where you can enjoy a leisurely meal and soak in the vibrant Naples scene.

What Food Critics Say

Campiello consistently receives high praise, often around 4.5 stars, for its beautiful outdoor dining, lively atmosphere, and authentic Tuscan cuisine. Reviewers frequently commend the fresh ingredients and the overall sophisticated dining experience, though some mention that it can be quite busy and reservations are highly recommended.

📍 Address: 1177 3rd St S, Naples, FL 34102

Get a Discount

Special offers available
Make a Reservation

Book your table now
Get Directions

Open in Google Maps

Scarola's Italian Restaurant

For a taste of classic, comforting Italian-American cuisine in Sarasota, Scarola's Italian Restaurant is a beloved local gem. This family-owned spot offers a warm, unpretentious atmosphere where you can relax and enjoy generous portions of your favorite Italian dishes. It's the kind of neighborhood place where you feel like part of the family, and the focus is truly on hearty, delicious food.

Their menu is packed with all the classics you crave: chicken parmigiana, lasagna, spaghetti and meatballs, and a fantastic selection of pizzas. Everything is made with care, and you can truly taste the homemade quality. The portions are famously generous, so come hungry! Pricing is very reasonable, typically $20-40 per person, making it an excellent choice for a casual family dinner, a relaxed meal with friends, or when you just want some good old-fashioned comfort food.

What Food Critics Say

Scarola's Italian Restaurant generally holds a strong 4.2-star rating, with diners frequently praising its generous portions, classic Italian-American comfort food, and friendly, family-like atmosphere. Many appreciate the value and the consistent quality, though some note that the decor is simple and not as upscale as other options.

📍 Address: 8405 Tuttle Ave, Sarasota, FL 34243

Get a Discount

Special offers available
Make a Reservation

Book your table now
Get Directions

Open in Google Maps

Pane & Vino

If you're in Miami Beach and want to witness the magic of fresh pasta being made right before your eyes, then Pane & Vino is your destination. This charming and intimate spot on Washington Avenue is famous for its "pasta lab" where chefs craft beautiful, fresh pasta daily, adding an incredible layer of authenticity and theater to your dining experience. It's cozy, romantic, and truly feels like a little piece of Italy.

Their menu is a celebration of fresh pasta, with dishes like Cacio e Pepe, Carbonara, and various ravioli options that are simply divine. Beyond pasta, they offer delicious antipasti and main courses, but the pasta is definitely the star of the show. The wine list is well-curated to complement the food. Pricing is mid-to-high range, typically $35-60 per person, offering a unique and memorable dining experience perfect for a date night or a special meal with a small group.

What Food Critics Say

Pane & Vino consistently earns high praise, often around 4.6 stars, for its incredibly fresh, house-made pasta and the unique experience of watching it being prepared. Reviewers frequently highlight the authentic flavors and the cozy, romantic ambiance, though some mention that the space is small and can feel a bit cramped when busy.

📍 Address: 1450 Washington Ave, Miami Beach, FL 33139

Get a Discount

Special offers available
Make a Reservation

Book your table now
Get Directions

Open in Google Maps