Top 10 Italian Restaurants in New York
2. L'Artusi
Oh, L'Artusi! This West Village darling is one of those places that just gets it right every single time. It's got a chic, modern vibe with a beautiful open kitchen that lets you peek at the culinary magic happening behind the scenes. The atmosphere is always buzzing, lively, and perfect for a date night or a fun dinner with friends. It strikes that perfect balance of being sophisticated without feeling stuffy, making everyone feel right at home.
Their pasta dishes are truly the stars here, especially the Tagliatelle with Bolognese and the Spaghetti with Uni. But honestly, everything on the menu, from their exquisite crudo to their perfectly cooked mains, is a testament to their commitment to fresh, seasonal ingredients. Expect to spend around $70-120 per person for a fantastic meal, which is a great value for the quality and experience you're getting. Locals know this is a go-to for consistently delicious Italian food, so reservations are highly recommended, especially on weekends.
What Food Critics Say
L'Artusi is celebrated for its consistently excellent modern Italian cuisine, particularly its pasta and crudo dishes. Boasting a strong 4.6-star rating, reviewers often highlight the vibrant atmosphere and the knowledgeable staff, though some note that the popularity means it can get quite loud during peak hours.